Mattitaco

I dunno its hard for me to not like a place like this but I wasnt impressed.. didnt take pics because there wasnt anything that was worth showing.... chicken burrito was small and full of lettuce.... 2 kids tacos were bland like "hamburger meat" my 6 year old said, also soft corn tortilla.... and the qt of Margaritas to go was full of ice and like 20 something dollars and didnt even get a buzzz... Sorry, maybe a good place when not in quarantine, but the front porch wasnt anything special to sit at, so i dont know.... and neither was the food. Also had a cheese quesadilla and a beer all for 63$.

Great food. Cooked to order. Very accommodating. Friendly wait staff. Good value.

Fantastic food and very friendly staff!

Great food! Such an awesome addition to the north fork. Staff was very friendly and helped us choose! Not dissapointed in the slightest. Would definitely eat there again

We drove an hour this morning out east just to get out of the house during this crazy time. A friend Recommened this place for tacos. Once we got there we found They were actually closed and only prepping for the rest of the week. When the guy working there found out what we were doing for the day they actually opened up for us and made us lunch. It was absolutely delicious we will definitely be back again and I highly recommend this place not only for the food but for the compassion that the employees have especially during this time.

Very delicious taco Tuesday buy one get one. A bit costly (la Croix was 3 bucks), food quickly prepared. I had a baha taco, panko breaded cod. 4" very fresh corn tortilla and Pico. So tasty, will definitely return.

Never got our food... waited for over an hour and finally called them. They told me their system crashed... the manager said he can take the order over the phone but we will have to wait another hour... worst customer service EVER! Not worth the time. Worst part is all the food spots are closed... so no dinner tonight!

The atmosphere is relaxing and the food is serious quality. Fresh and local. Combinations that keep me going back. I'm hooked.

This place is worth a try. They have big portions for reasonable rates. Regularly well organized and with great character. Will come visit again.

Fast, friendly and super delicious!

Cold and greasy, Better off going to lucharitos a few mins down the road!!

Love Mattitaco! I eat here all the time and get takeout pretty often as well, the food is always great and the staff is friendly and very accommodating to my dietary restrictions. Don't forget to try their hot sauces, they are incredible!

Food was amazing!! Definitely worth the trip. The owner couldn't be more friendly!!

Stellar experience. Super friendly people, good vibes and excellent food. I had two tacos, a Sweetness and a Hawaiian...when I was done I was sucking my fingers to get every last bit. Nice beer selection.Some of the negative reviews think the prices are high.a). They're wrong. Good, fast or cheap - you can get any two of the three, you can't get all three!b). There's always Taco Bell

Awesome little place. Amazing food, friendly staff and cool, relaxed atmosphere. Just a heads up, tips are cash only so be sure to have some cash on hand.

I just liked their food. I always get good service here. The place is well kept and the employees are always welcoming. Keep up the good work.

Super cute place. Great tacos with unique flavors. Awesome homemade hot sauces.

Chill spot for flavorful, innovative tacos. Was pleasantly surprised by a variety of kombuchas on tap. The surf taco was made even more amazing with orange, pineapple habañero hot sauce... paired with a honey jalapeño kombucha.

My wife and I love trying new taco place but these tacos where very underwhelming. They try to be creative with the menu and options but it honestly doesn’t work for the taco portion. Sometimes it’s easier to be simple when it comes to the tacos. I think Yelp reviews were more accurate on the place and how good the food is. Don’t come here for the tacos get a burrito or quesadilla. If I was just rating the tacos I probably would have give the place 1 star but the other food wasn’t bad. The tacos are tasteless and the use of cabbage is excessive to disguise the fact they don’t put much in the tacos (besides the cod). Sauce is very mayonnaise tasting and doesn’t go well with the taco. The tacos are 5-6 bucks each which I think is to much give what you get. Probably won’t come back or go out of my way to come here again.

Cute local place with interesting tacos. I had the BLT - Bacon, Lobster and Tomato taco as well as a scallop taco special. I didn't expect the scallops to be deep fried. I has a side of brussel sprouts that were deep fried and super greasy. I was a take out customer, so maybe there was a lack of attention to detail, but it wasn't a wonderful experience. Could have been an off night -- we all have them.

Great way to end a day if drinking at the vineyards. Great food and staff. On the smaller side inside than expected but the food made up for that immensely

My grandmother and I stopped here after much debate and needless to say we had a fantastic experience and dinner. The lady was nice and described everything to us and we settled and when we got home we were in heaven with our food tasting great and fresh. Thanks again we will be back!

Perfect spot! The menu is great. Food is fresh perfection. I ordered the baja taco and the Mexican corn. My husband had a burrito from the specials menu. The people who work there couldn’t be nicer. Comfortable outside seating too. The TShirts are adorable. This is definitely a new regular for breakfast, lunch, or dinner (or take out).

This little taco place in Mattituck is an amazing place to eat. Great Great Food!!!!! Great staff and service.

What a lovely little spot! The atmosphere is bright and cheery, the tunes were poppin', and the staff were so kind and helpful. I ordered 2 of their vegan tacos (jackfruit carnitas - nice and spicy! and the sweet potato brussel sprouts - love the crispiness of the veg and the rioja salsa). Their chips and salsa and guacamole were also super flavorful. Highly recommend this spot for a bite.

Great new place...interesting and creative twists on tacos and burritos. Especially love they serve breakfast and a great cold brew. I often get bored of standard breakfast items. Switch it up with breakfast burritos and tacos instead. Love the hot sauce with pineapple in it.

Excellent seafood tacos. Homemade handmade corn tortilla guac and salsa. Awesome. Unique beverages and the owner can be heard singing along to the music. A "Whaley good taco!!"

Food was okay, the waitress seemed a little clueless. Couldn't answer a majority of our questions about the food. Loaded plantains were very good

Good food & service. Nice people.

Good food, great people working there. I had 3 tacos and they all had great flavor, one could have used a bit more sauce. Staff was extremely sweet. Will go again.

Awesome!!! Great food, great service, great people. Will be our regular go to

Accidentally found this gem! Such great food & service.

Best tacos !!

Fresh and tasty tacos. Staff was friendly. Moderately priced. Currently is BYOB. Not sure how long that will last since I saw wine taps behind the counter. Tried the Baha Taco.

The food here is 'WHALEY' Good..

I truly have no idea how someone could have given a 1-Star. I was fortunate enough to enjoy three impromptu tacos from their food truck, "On the Road" outside North Fork Brewing. They were spectacular. Arguably 3 of the best tacos I've ever had. Arthur was manning the helm that day and not only were the tacos delicious, but the value was great. I had a Farm to Taco taco, with roasted veggies. A shrimp and chorizo taco, and a pulled pork and pineapple taco. If you see this food truck, you would do well to take the opportunity to indulge.

Friendly staff, good food. Great place to go for a bite after a day at the beach or shopping. Unique choices of tacos that will never leave you bored.

Amazing place for vegan and non vegans alike! Their assortment of hot sauces is really on point. From Mexican sodas to locally sourced ingredients you really can’t go wrong here. It’s worth sitting and eating in given the stylish ambiance and cute whale motif but they’re great for takeout, too.

Mattitaco is a revelation in taco technology! Uses the best local ingredients and the boldest flavors. Prepare to experience a revolution.

In the past the vegetarian options have been stellar but just got 2 shroom tacos that were loaded with raw cabbage and only had a few little slices of mushroom on top. For 6 dollars a taco I'm pretty disappointed. Our cheese quesadilla was a little over done aswell............

Try the BLT taco..the best. Casual, good food....The very best tacos.

I always come grabbing some food in here. I love the speedy service and well made dishes. 5 stars from me.

You need these tacos! We ordered a bunch, then wound up ordering seconds!! Delicious food and friendly staff! They even feature rotating local art!

This restaurant is amazing and roomy, the menu was enchanting and the prices were very fair. quickly, effective service and very welcoming staff. I highly recommend this place.

Great food

Really liked it but they seem to have taken the "Rustica" off the menu which was my favorite since I have to avoid spicy things and also love portobello so the combo was amazing with the steak. We were big fans maybe it could come back?! I hope was maybe a seasonal thing or something. Bring back the rustic please! Loved ordering online modern and smart unlike some other places out here

I found my perfect order in a "Just Because" with added chicken!

Staff is excellent and inviting. The food is fresh and delicious. Mattitaco is a must try, you will not regret it.

Fresh food. Super nice staff.

This is my second time here, last time was a year ago and we stayed to eat, everything was perfect. However Yesterday I went and made a very simple order of 3 tacos, loaded plantains and dirty fries, we waited an hour and a half for the food to be ready, the food is great, but there is no reason to wait an hour and a half for such an small order, also while we waited they should’ve offered us water. My sister had to ask for water and we got an apology at the very end when they saw we were already extremely frustrated. From my point of view they should’ve warned us of the waiting time at the time we made the order. Place is nice, food is great, but bathroom was dirty and the waiting time was just too much.